| # |
YEAR |
WINNER |
RUNNER-UP |
3RD PLACE |
4TH PLACE |
| 1 | 1982 | Helen Scheerbaum | | | |
| 2 | 1983 | Lorraine Sztenderowicz | Helen Scheerbaum | Dorriee Sullivan | Kass Bajor |
| 3 | 1984 | Helen Scheerbaum | Pat Leslie | Adele Nutter | Pat Bizuk |
| 4 | 1985 | Robin White | | | |
| 5 | 1986 | Peany Colavecci | | | |
| 6 | 1987 | Mary Jo Deitch | Donna Niedosik | | |
| 7 | 1988 | Mary Jo Deitch | | | |
| 8 | 1989 | Mary Jo Deitch | | | |
| 9 | 1990 | Mary Jo Deitch | | | |
| 10 | 1991 | Mary Jo Deitch | | | |
| 11 | 1992 | Helen Scheerbaum | | | |
| 12 | 1993 | Mary Jo Deitch | Cathy Vogt? | | |
| 13 | 1994 | Mary Jo Deitch | Joyce Hamilton | | |
| 14 | 1995 | Mary Jo Deitch | Frannie Frederick | Cindy Quartana | Helen Scheerbaum |
| 15 | 1996 | Mary Jo Chesney | Lori Kelly? | | |
| 16 | 1997 | Mary Jo Chesney | Martina Sweeney | Joyce Hamilton | Kelly Gallagher |
| 17 | 1998 | Mary Jo Chesney | Cheryl Smith | | |
| 18 | 1999 | Mary Jo Chesney | Joyce Hamilton | Helen Scheerbaum | F Frederick |
| 19 | 2000 | Mary Jo Chesney | Ginger Plies? | | |
| 20 | 2001 | Mary Jo Chesney | Joyce Hamilton | Helen Scheerbaum | Steph Hughes |
| 21 | 2002 | Fran Frederick | Helen Scheerbaum | Mary Jo Chesney | Lois Cornwall |
| 22 | 2003 | Mary Jo Chesney | Helen Scheerbaum | | |
| 23 | 2004 | Helen Scheerbaum | Mary Jo Chesney | Joyce Hamilton | Alice Trago |
| 24 | 2005 | Joyce Hamilton | Ginger Plies? | | |
| 25 | 2006 | Mary Jo Chesney | Terri Marcello | | C Smith Lentine |
| 26 | 2007 | Terri Marcello | Mary Jo Chesney | Joyce Hamilton | Theresa Mc |
| 27 | 2008 | Mary Jo Chesney | Carmen DeRose | Joyce Hamilton | Terri Marcello |
| 28 | 2009 | Mary Jo Chesney | | | |
| 29 | 2010 | Terri Marcello | Carmen Reed | Joyce Hamilton | Kelly Gallagher |
| 30 | 2011 | Joyce Hamilton | Theresa Sieger | Kelly Gallagher | Michele Dolan |
| 31 | 2012 | Mary Jo Chesney | Maria Ingram | Joyce Hamilton | Carmen Reed |
| 32 | 2013 | Mary Jo Chesney | Brittany Jasinski | Terri Marcello | Paige Dolan |
| 33 | 2014 | Brittany Jasinski | Carmen Reed | Paige Dolan | Jamie Spingler |
| 34 | 2015 | Mary Jo Chesney | Brittany Jasinski | Paige Dolan | Jess Melon |
| 35 | 2016 | Brittany Jasinski | Mary Jo Chesney | Lauren Wakal | Jess Melon |
| 36 | 2017 | Mary Jo Chesney | Jaime Spingler | Brittany Jasinski | Lauren Wakal |
| 37 | 2018 | Mary Jo Chesney | Kate Bryant | Kari McDonnell | Ashley Boltz |
| 38 | 2019 | Brittany Jasinski | Ashley Boltz | Pam Harly | Kate Bryant |
| 39 | 2020 | Casey Hare | Brittany Jasinski | Paige Dolan | Kari McDonnell |
| 40 | 2021 | Brittany Jasinski | Mary Jo Chesney | Lil Ramos | Jamie Spingler |
| 41 | 2022 | Paige Dolan | Brittany Jasinski | Jess O'Brien | Casey Hare |
| 42 | 2023 | Colleen Russell | Brittany Jasinski | Lil Ramos | Jamie Spingler |
| 43 | 2024 | Colleen Russell | Jessica O'Brien | Jamie Spingler | Brittany Jasinski |
| 44 | 2025 | Brittany Jasinski | Colleen Russell | Katrina Dolan | Laura Stankiewicz |
| 45 | 2026 | Colleen Russell | Tiffany Jasinski | Katrina Dolan | Stephanie Wehrman |
